Did Doctors Really Masturbate Their Female Patients to Cure Hysteria?
One journalist is trying to whitewash this disgusting history.
If you enjoyed this article, please share it with a friend or consider becoming a paid subscriber. Wednesday’s article is always free. Sunday’s article is for paid subscribers only.
You have probably heard the twisted yarn by now. Medieval physicians once believed hysteria in women was caused by bad "seed" — pent-up sexual arousal. So they masturbated their female patients until they reached "hysterical paroxysm" — orgasm. At first, they manually stimulated women, but once the vibrator was invented in the nineteenth century, doctors were saved from carpal tunnel.
It's the classic "necessity as the mother of invention" tale with a pervy twist.
What's not to love?
Unfortunately, journalist Hallie Lieberman doesn't love this grim chapter in medical history and has been on a crusade to rewrite it. She claims doctors never masturbated their patients and focuses her attack on historian Rachel P. Maines' critically acclaimed book on the history of vibrators, The Technology of Orgasm.
Lieberman doesn't mince words. She writes, "Technology of Orgasm represents a failure in academic quality control."
Ouch.
So, who is right? Are the accusations of diddling doctors hyperbolic, or are the rumors even worse than we imagined?
Let's unpack this historian’s catfight.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Conversations with Carlyn to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.